Tags: online chess, online chess, play chess, online chess, chess online, chess online, online backgammon
Chess Forum uskidscompute.com << online chess - < chess - chess > - chess online >>
| From | Message | Posted by punkusmartyrus uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 16:06:05 Play online chess | Subject: Drawing a won game?
Message: board #5929374
by move 36, Black was willing to trade off his knight for a draw game due to the openess of the position, but Black was up +2. Was the draw a mistake? Was there some other way Black could of cashed in on the +2 advantage to bring in a win?
| Posted by sough uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 16:47:31 Play online chess |
Message: I think it's too simple to look at it as "-2". White has massive pressure with all 3 major pieces. Black has the passed h pawn but probably won't have time to push it. Unless there is some exchange combination or defensive move that I'm missing, I think black made a wise decision.
| Posted by coyotefan uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 18:00:04 Play online chess | Good points
Message: Remember, chess is not Baseball. You do not win on points. I opposed the +/- informaton being put on the GK screen when it was done for just this reason. I would rather be -9 and have mate in 2 than be +9 and about to be mated.
Feel free to look at both my active and completed games and se how many games I won with a 'minus or zero score'. Also when looking at my active games realize that virtually every game (only 2 are not) against an under 2000 opponent is totally won, while the score may not reflect that. ——— World's No. 1 Chess Player Widens Lead Over His Biggest Rivals — History will record 1990 as a great year for chess players: it was when three of the current top 25 players in the world were born. The youngest of the three is Magnus Carlsen of Norway, who is No. 1 in the world. Of the other two, Maxime Vachier-Lagrave of France is No. 18, and Sergey Karjakin, who was born in Ukraine but now plays for Russia, is No. 21. Under different circumstances, Karjakin and Vachier-Lagrave would be considered potential world chess champions. But just as the talented players in the 2003 N.B.A. draft have labored in LeBron James’s shadow, Karjakin and Vachier-Lagrave have been eclipsed by Carlsen. In Karjakin’s case, it is puzzling. He was the youngest ...
Posted by ionadowman uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 22:39:02 Play online chess | Is there anything against...
Message: ... Black playing, say, 40...Ra7!?
The position after White's 40th is:
b
Now, suppose Black were to play 40...Ra7, pinning the White Q. 41.Rb5+ Ka8 42.R6b6 and now Black can not take: 42...Rxa6 43.Rxa6#
But how about just exploiting the remote pawn (42...h3)? Has White any redress? 43.Rh6 h2; or 43.Ka4 h2 44.Qxa7+ Kxa7 45.Rb7+ Ka8 46.R7b6 Qd4+ with 47...Qxb6 to follow.
(At that, the whole thing might have worked better at move 38, when the Black Q stood at d4: 38...Ra7 39.Rb5+ Ka8 40.R6b6 h3 ... White is in even worse zugzwang, by the looks. Say 41.c3 Qxb6! 42.Rxb6 Rh1! 43.Qxa7 Kxa7 and the rook can't get back in time to stop the h-pawn. Note that Black ought not to play 40...Qxb6 before advancing the h-pawn, as then the White rook does get back to stop the h-pawn.)
Seems, punkusmartyrus, that, unless there is an even more hidden resource for White, you had more than a draw after all...
;-)
——— Vishy Anand helps Magnus Carlsen to claim Corus crown — When Vishy Anand drew his first nine games at Corus Wijk aan Zee last week, opinions were divided on whether the world chess champion had lost his edge or was simply taking a well-paid rest before his April title defence in Sofia against Veselin Topalov. Then Anand acted as Corus king-maker, beating Alexei Shirov and Vlad Kramnik, so that the pair finished half a point behind Magnus Carlsen. Norway's world No1 had previously won at Pearl Spring in China and the London Classic and finished second at the Tal Memorial, His fine run continued at Wijk, and the live ratings now make him the all-time No2 to Garry Kasparov. Carlsen had final-round luck in Holland, and the impression is that ...
Posted by ionadowman uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 23:37:02 Play online chess | H'mmm....
Message: ... As it turns out, I should have looked a little further into the ending that ensued after the White rook gives itself up for Black's h-pawn. This needed to be investigated, and it turns out that White can hold this ending (it's probably standard technique) especially considering that they are joined flank pawns, and the enemy K is directly in front of them. Something like this:
w
So the move to pin the White Queen by ...Ra7 don't work, after all (though it comes bally close!)
:-( ——— Fresh ideas from Adams — The Governor of Gibraltar Sir Adrian Johns visited the Gibtelecom Masters at the Caleta Hotel and chose the day the chess competition intensified as England’s Michael Adams regained a share of the lead with a ninth round win. Adams produced a new idea in the opening against the French Defence and although it did not look particularly dangerous he gradually outplayed the Argentinian GM Damian Lemos to reach 7/9. All the games were hardfought with the exception of the top board where the leader at start of play Jan Gustafsson was content to force an early draw against top seed Etienne Bacrot. With one to play Adams shares the lead with ...
Posted by far1ey uskidscompute.com
10/14/2006 23:39:48 Play online chess |
Message: Well you probably shoulda tried to promote H pawn while keeping the queens on the board which probably woulda led to draw despite the material. If H pawn lost, no worry queens and rooks will probably give a draw. If H pawn converts then better for you.
Just a thought did you consider Rxc2?I think white gets away but just wondering... ——— Jan Gustafsson breaks away — If there was a traffic jam after seven rounds of the GibTelecom Masters there is gridlock after eight although GM Jan Gustafsson of Germany started speeding and broke away from the pack by defeating WGM Natalia Zhukova with black. Eight of the co-leaders at start of play drew, two lost and only Gustafsson reached 6.5/8 with over a dozen chess players on 6 points. Michael Adams held former US chess champion and FIDE championship finalist Gata Kamsky to a draw with black and the pair are in the group on 6. The top seed Etienne Bacrot is also on 6/8. He made a slow start but is back in contention. In the following game he employs the Moldovan Variation of ...
Posted by kewms uskidscompute.com
10/15/2006 08:52:23 Play online chess |
Message: As others have pointed out, material alone is not enough to evaluate a position. That's especially true when the material advantage is relatively small. In this case, for instance, suppose that all the "equal" material gets swapped off, leaving a knight against 2 pawns. Black still has an advantage, but it isn't enough to win. White still has a material deficit, but he also has the only winning chances.
With that said, I don't think I would have swapped off the knight, at least not yet. In the position at move 36, it seems to me that Black should be able to hold off White's threats -- exchanging material if necessary -- long enough to make the h-pawn a factor. The knight's forking potential is likely to be a big help, while the Q-side pawns are not yet an offensive force. But this is off the top of my head, and jet-lagged to boot, so shouldn't be taken as gospel.
Katherine ——— The Scotch Opening, part 4: what does White do next? — Fashions come and go in chess. And this is is one that may well be on the way back. 4... Bc5 is one of Black's main options against the Scotch chess opening (1 e4 e5 2 Nf3 Nc6 3 d4 exd4 4 Nxd4). How should White continue? RB I've done a tiny bit of study on the Scotch and so am not quite the total novice I was when we began this survey. In fact, I've reached this position in a couple of recent casual games. I've tried both of White's two principal continuations here, 5 Nxc6 and 5 Be3 (5 Nb3 is less often seen). The first of these looks appealing for White: 5...dxc6 6 Qxd8+ Kxd8 puts an end to Black's castling ...
Posted by ionadowman uskidscompute.com
10/15/2006 12:32:22 Play online chess | far1ey...
Message: ... Rxc2 does impose itself on one's consciousness, doesn't it? It doesn't work, though. Black just doesn't have enough.
As for trying to promote the h-pawn before exchanging Queens, White can force them off himself, betimes. All the same, I think the position can stand a bit more study...
Kewms's remark about material vs immaterial considerations is pertinent. The Rook vs 3 Pawns ending, given the likely arrangement of the pieces (i.e. spatial and temporal considerations) in this instance, seems to be drawn, despite the +2 advantage. But then, we all know the +4 advantage book draw of K+wrong B + RP vs lone K, don't we?
| Posted by ionadowman uskidscompute.com
10/15/2006 13:15:56 Play online chess | More on 40...Ra7
Message: It looks as though White has an easier road to the draw than I thought:
Recall the position:
b
After 40...Ra7, White has
41.Rb5+ Ka8 42.Rb4! h3 43.Qxa7! Kxa7 44.Ra4+ Kb7 45.Rb4+ and one way on another, Black has to give up the Q to retain any winning chances: 45...Kc7 46.Rc4+ Qxc4 47.bxc4 Rh8 48.Re1, after which Black has to save the draw (probably not difficult).
White can give up his Q a move earlier:
41.Rb5+ Ka8 42.Qxa7+!? Kxa7 43.Re4 Ka6 44.Rh5 Rc5 45.Rhxh4 Ra5+ 46.Ra4 Qc5+ 47.Kb2 Qe5+ 48.c3 Qe2+ 49.Ka3 Rxa4+ 50.Rxa4+ Kb5 51.Rf4 etc, and White can fancy his chances of holding the draw.
So it looks as though kewms is right: that the win for Black has to be found earlier than move 40 at least and probably earlier than move 38...
| Posted by punkusmartyrus uskidscompute.com
10/16/2006 12:21:43 Play online chess | Thanx..
Message: for all the feed back. I'm unsure if I considered 27... Rxc2+, most likely not, but I don't see any continuation with it that favors white better than drawing chances.
| Posted by punkusmartyrus uskidscompute.com
10/16/2006 12:23:01 Play online chess | sorry,
Message: I meant black better than drawing chances.
| Posted by jsemmens uskidscompute.com
10/16/2006 16:53:28 Play online chess | 40. ... Ra7??
Message: actually, 40...Ra7 turns out to be a disaster for black:
41. Rb5+ 41. Ka8
42. Rb7 1-0
or:
41. Rb5+ Kc7
42. Re7+ Kd8
43. Qxa7 1-0
Black probably made the right descision by going for a draw I believe.
| Posted by bogg uskidscompute.com
10/16/2006 18:58:20 Play online chess | jsemmens
Message: You might want to look at the position after 42. Rb7 one more time.
CTC (Bogg)
| Posted by punkusmartyrus uskidscompute.com
10/17/2006 13:13:33 Play online chess | hmm...
Message: 40...Ra7
41. Rb5+ 41. Ka8
42. Rb7 Rxa6+
Would have won, no?
| Posted by ionadowman uskidscompute.com
10/18/2006 00:14:48 Play online chess | Would have won, yes...
Message: ... easy mistake to make. It does look like a mate, seen 2-3 moves ahead, and practice of this kind will help improve the vision. For anyone who still don't see it:
40...Ra7
41.Rb5+ Ka8
42.Rb7?? Rxa6+
43.Rxa6+ Kxb7 with a quick win for Black.
Cheers, Ion
|
| | | | |
|